Iconic New York City Landmark At Risk Of Being Demolished

Papaya King, an iconic New York City landmark, may soon see its final days as it's at risk of being completely demolished.

By Joseph Farago | Published

papaya king new york city

New York City is home to many notable landmarks like the Statue of Liberty and the High Line. The city is also, of course, a hub for fancy cuisine and authentic foods from all around the world. Though you might not have heard of it, a particular Manhatten restaurant is just as iconic as some of the better-known landmarks. The Papaya King, a hot dog and tropical drink joint is a city staple that may be closing down soon.

The Papaya King was founded in 1932 in the city’s Upper East Side neighborhood. Since then, the hot dog shop has accumulated an extensive fan base, with many tourists ensuring they visit the restaurant during their trips. It’s the only Papaya King in the five New York boroughs and has garnered a considerable reputation for its hot dogs and fruity drinks. In a pricey city, the one-story building stands as an anomaly among the towers of luxury apartment buildings. Unfortunately, this has threatened the prosperity of Papaya King’s enterprise.

Some residents have noticed specific signs leading to Papaya King’s rumored closing. On Patch, an American local news and information platform, a New York journalist posted about plans to demolish the restaurant. An NYC developer called Extell filed plans to tear down the one-story building. Though it’s not clear what the developers intend to create, Papaya King will most likely turn into a luxury high-rise if demolished. Though not confirmed, Extell bought the lot that Papya King resides on for over $21 million.

Since the news broke on Patch, other journalists and more significant newspapers reported on the alleged plan. No one has gotten a comment from Papaya King owners or Extell spokespeople to confirm if the demolishing will occur anytime soon. Ever since the news was disclosed on Patch, New York City residents have been flocking to the restaurant in case the building closes unexpectedly. The restaurant has reported massive traffic since the news reached the residents, with many regarding Papaya King as a quintessential Manhattan staple. With almost 90 years of business, many locals can’t fathom the Upper East Side without the hot dog joint.

Richard Barnet, an 80-year-old NYC resident, talked to NPR about his longstanding attendance of Papaya King. He stated that the hot dogs were “as good 70 years ago,” a true testament to the quality and consistency of the restaurant. He believes that it doesn’t only showcase the hot dog restaurant’s success but that ordinary residents can understand high-quality food.

Unfortunately, Papaya King’s one-story building is an inevitable target for city developers. The Upper East Side is one of the most expensive neighborhoods in Manhatten, which developers relentlessly try to cash in on. The fact that Papaya King’s lot holds so much potential to make more money has created problems for the restaurant’s longevity. Peter Poulos, son of Papaya King’s founder, commented on the real estate scene in New York City. “It’s too valuable of a corner,” he said, referring to the restaurant’s expected demise.

Though Papaya King may be coming to a close, residents will remember it as the premier hot dog joint for almost 100 years. Locals have been flooding the shop recently, hoping to order one last dog before it disappears.